Use a broad list when you are still exploring.
It works when you are still stumbling onto categories and trying to get a rough feel for what is out there. If you are still deciding between shoes, jackets, or bags, the broad view can help.
Comparison
When a big list helps, and when it gets in the way
A broad list is fine when you are still figuring things out. It becomes less helpful once you know exactly what you want.
Use a category page when you already know what you want.
Once you are past discovery, grouped browsing feels better. You stop opening irrelevant listings and start making tighter comparisons. That is where the giant list starts to lose its appeal.
Ready to narrow it down?
Start with the main CNFans index, then move into the section that matches what you are looking for.